ALB wrote:Was that because

#94795
LBird
Participant
ALB wrote:
Was that because they [the ICC] don't like the word "democracy" at all and never use it in a positive sense?

To be fair, the suggestion seemed to cause some confusion, and some posters appeared thoughtful about the implications, but for others, the very idea of humans controlling their science seemed to be a completely mad idea!Communism? What next? Free access to our wives, daughters and science?! Good Lord!Bourgeois sensibilities were outraged!Which brings me reluctantly to… [ahem]…

ALB wrote:
I don't understand what you are getting at. Obviously scientific and research establishment will be organised and run, like any other workplace, on a democratic basis, but you seem to be saying more: that the findings of such establishments should be subject to a democratic vote as to whether they are valid or not.

[my bold]Surely 'validity' is a human construct?Or are we going to have a 'Validity Central Committee', to keep those democracy-worshipping masses from poking their ignorant noses into matters that don't concern them?

ALB wrote:
Is that another lead balloon I can see crashing to the ground?

The ICC/SPGB Joint Scientific Authority airship? I hope so!I'll be helping to staff the proletarian 'human science' ack-ack defences: I hope you'll join me, comrade!