Ed wrote:You can have a

#94765
LBird
Participant
Ed wrote:
You can have a theory based on the best evidence available,…

But 'theories' predate 'evidence', as you go on to show in the second half of your statement.

Ed wrote:
… for instance the Higgs Boson particle which was predicted to exist before thay could actually find it because it was the most likely outcome based on the evidence they already had.

[my bold]'Evidence' is garnered after a theory is formulated by humans. Unfortunately, as every theory already contains assumptions and axioms, many of which determine just what is acceptable as 'evidence' for the 'theory', we can't get out of this problem by a positivist, inductive method, which claims to start from the unvarnished 'data/evidence'.That is the 'scientific method'. Acceptance of biases in human scientists, and that 'scientists' belong to social classes and have ideological views.

Ed wrote:
On the other hand you can have an unfounded theory, for instance, God or human nature. These theories are unfounded and have no objective evidence backing them up, the scientific view in this instance is to discard them as they have no validity.

'Science' just doesn't work like this. We now know that a 'theory' can determine its 'evidence'. If the theory has a axiom of 'the existence of god', it's still a 'valid theory'. That's why we have so much trouble with 'scientists' who lecture us about 'human nature'. They don't share our ideological assumptions. They have bourgeois assumptions, we have proletarian assumtions. But they are still 'scientists'.

Ed wrote:
For me ideology is to discard evidence in favour of an idea which best suits your needs, just like God. So yeah I think socialists should endeavour to discard all ideology and only base their theories on the scientific method.

I'm afraid your notion of 'the scientific method', as a supposedly objective, non-ideological, unpartisan 'method', is the… [gulp] long discredited bourgeois one. Sorry to be the bearer of ill-tidings, comrade.'Science' itself is an ideological minefield.