To talk about absolute

#94727
Sotionov
Participant

To talk about absolute post-scarcity is to delude oneself with technological utopianism that dreams about Star Trek becoming reality, with 'replicators' making eveything we need, and machines doing all the work, maybe even making and repairing themselves. That's a topic for a Trekkie convention, not for people wanting to abolish capitalism.Exaclty- people don't like to do certain jobs, and it is likely they would not miraculously start liking to do them in a socialist society. If we stop imagining a Trekkie utopia where all hard, dirty and dangerous work will not exist being done by machines, we need to ask ourselves how will we make sure that such work will get done. We don't like to do stuff, but we still do them- why? Because there are forces that make us experience consequences for not doing them. If i don't clean my house, it's going to turn into a hazardous and inhabitable pile of waste, and I'd have to move out and live on the street or rent a place or buy a new one. The only difference would be that in a socialist society forces that motivate people to do the unpleasant work would be removed, and people would have all the incentive to stop doing it. Let someone else do it, I have free access to everything. If my place turns into a waste pit, what do I care, I'll just go into another place, it's free.The only way I see free access can be possible is with either the utopian concept of the new man or with technological utopianism, and I see neither as a fitting guiding-idea for a socialist movement.If a view is to be presented that we should not abolish oppression and exploitation until one of those two ideas arise, I find that a particullary grim view, and just another attempt at justification of the wrong of the current system.