ralfy wrote:ALB wrote:This
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Whatever happened to “peak oil”? › ralfy wrote:ALB wrote:This
That's what I am doing, but I don't think you understand even the basics of this issue, which is why I had to address your first post by raising points that you did not consider. AFAIK, you did not counter any of my arguments and still believe that "doomsayers" are wrong. Given that, wouldn't it be pedantic to ask for solutions for a problem that you insist does not exist?
The way I see it, this is not a debatable issue, unless there is something that I stated earlier that you still question. Otherwise, I will wait and see if you acknowledge peak oil as a problem. That is the only way for me to see your request for solutions as relevant.
I've implied previously that I for one – having followed the argument for several years – are interested in this subject. But I do not place any trust in the evidence from both sides. On the one hand OPEC and other major oil producers will never reveal the real reasons for any decrease in production capacity. Therefore all the so called evidence that oil production has peaked (or is on the verge of peaking) are based on present consumption figures and the assumption that oil well pressure is falling globally due to wells running dry. Obviously, through having being denied the true figures the doomsayers are on rocky ground when moving the argument from reaching an assumption and then making a conclusion. Which means in effect their predictions are all based on possible problems and not probable problems.Nevertheless, despite the lack of accurate science I am prepared in this instance to give the doomsayers the benefit of the doubt. Because being a socialists its in my interest to be prepared for such an eventuality possibly occurring. And more importantly so I'm in a position to counter the negative solutions which undoubtedly are on offer.To date ralfy agreed that there is no solution for peak oil within the framework of capitalism but nevertheless has failed to agree that a solution is to be found within the socialist system advocated by the wsm/spgb. I have to assume, therefore he has his own solution but is keeping it under wraps in his own self-interest. To adopt such a fence sitting attitude does nothing to move the discussion forward and ultimately places the discussion locked in the time warp of the 1970's with all the scaremongering of the end of growth, etc.That said and if I'm correct ralfy is also on very rocky ground simply due to the fact that any solution he may have on offer needs to go through a rigrious and robust examination to ensure its not just another logical fallacy and before its in danger of falling into the trap of self-delusion.
