ALB wrote:This seems a bit

#94303
ralfy
Participant
ALB wrote:
This seems a bit pedantic. I would have thought that it made sense to discuss all aspects of "peak oil" on one thread.

That's what I am doing, but I don't think you understand even the basics of this issue, which is why I had to address your first post by raising points that you did not consider. AFAIK, you did not counter any of my arguments and still believe that "doomsayers" are wrong. Given that, wouldn't it be pedantic to ask for solutions for a problem that you insist does not exist?

Quote:
This is not just a dialogue between you and me. I may have started this thread but there are others on this forum who probably won't take the same position as me (in fact I was assuming some won't) and will be interested in hearing your solution to the problem you and they perceive.

The way I see it, this is not a debatable issue, unless there is something that I stated earlier that you still question. Otherwise, I will wait and see if you acknowledge peak oil as a problem. That is the only way for me to see your request for solutions as relevant.

Quote:
Well, at least that confirms that you are not a lobbyist for some rival source of energy to drive capitalist industry, e.g nuclearpower but it still leaves open the question of how you propose to deal with the problem. Are we to just sit around and wait for the capitalist system to fall apart? Or should we take to the hills, as the doomsters advise?

I don't see nuclear power as a "rival source of energy" due to the absence of petrochemicals, the difficulty of using it for ship transport, the lack of portability for smaller vehicles, the fact that it also faces problems similar to oil and other physical resources, and the point that in terms of the environment it can be just as dangerous as oil, if not worse.