ALB wrote:This discussion

#94294
ralfy
Participant
ALB wrote:
This discussion echos the one in this debate:http://www.worldsocialism.org/spgb/video/poles-apart-capitalism-or-socialism-planet-heatsand which puts us in the invidious position of seeming to say that capitalism is not as bad as some say it is ! In this debate the speaker for Arctic Voice is saying that capitalism is doomed because it won't be able to deal with global warming while the SP speaker is saying maybe it can, not that that makes capitalism any less undesirable and socialism any less necessary.Here you are saying (or seem to be saying) that capitalism's appetite for oil will mean that it will eventually breakdown because it will exhaust oil reserves and won't be able to find an efficient alternative. I'm arguing that maybe it can find an alternative (or even enough oil) and that it won't collapse for this reason.But whichever of us is right, socialism is still the answer. If you are right, then it is only within a socialist world that the effects of peak oil/global warming could be mitigated. In fact it would make socialism and campaigning for it even more urgent as, if capitalism were to collapse before there was a majority in favour of socialism, all the dystopian films about the collapse of civilisation could turn out to be realistic.

I believe that the problem is a combination of predicaments: peak oil, debt-ridden economic crisis, and global warming coupled with environmental damage. Wars and epidemics which will be driven by these predicaments will make things worse.Theroetically, it is possible tor replace fossil fuels but it will take decades:http://www.businessinsider.com/131-years-to-replace-oil-2010-11and will involve issues such as an energy trap:http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/10/the-energy-trap/not to mention extensive cooperation and coordination between governments, as mentioned by the IEA. But as pointed out earlier, that won't take place.In which case, we should expect no alternatives to allow for "business as usual" until it is too late.In addition, we should not expect global warming to be mitigated, either, for similar reasons.Finally, in order to see socialism as "the answer," we need to understand the points that I've raised concerning peak oil and argue that they are true. Otherwise, one will end up ironically repeating what capitalists say: that global warming is either a hoax or a non-issue because it will be mitigated easily, that peak oil is a hoax because there is lots of oil still available or a non-issue because in case there isn't enough oil we can find alternatives easily, and that anyone who insists otherwise is nothing more than a doomsayer.