ALB wrote:Tom Rogers wrote:I
November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Race, Gender and Class › ALB wrote:Tom Rogers wrote:I
My reference was to people who consciously decide to marry/have children with someone they considered to be of the same "racial group" as them. You are talking of people who might "instinctively" do this. I doubt that this is a human "instinct" if only because of people of the millions of people who don't do this (the reason why me and others described your claim about this to be nonsense) but also because one of the features of the human species is to have very little instinctual behaviour.
It depends on how one should define 'instinct' and 'consciousness' respectively and how one sees the relationship between the two. I see consciousness as a formation of both instinct and intellect. I accept that intellect can override instinctive behaviours, but I also probably ascribe greater importance to instinct than you do.You refer to "millions of people" who don't form relationships on the basis of what I define (roughly-speaking) as kin instincts: it would be good to see evidence for this. While I don't necessarily doubt that is true, I would suggest that such people are overriding an instinct to procreate within their own racial or ethnic group. In your view, that is a good thing. In my view, it might not necessarily always be a good thing, but no matter how you define the terminology, I don't see how you can deny that historically and prehistorically humans have mated within genetically-cohesive social groups. The rest, whether you think consciousness should override this is, to me, a normative point. You either agree with it or you don't. I don't necessarily.
