SocialistPunk wrote:The

#90385
Brian
Participant
SocialistPunk wrote:
The following exert comes from the last paragraph of the Int Dept report into OGW's second suspension. "Note: On the internal Party forums hosted by Yahoo, there is a facility for moderators to place users' posts in a queue for moderator attention. This is used when someone has been deemed to be abusive. It means that for a short time, when the moderated user posts a new message, it goes first of all to the moderator, rather than the forum. This allows the forum to remain clear of escalating problems, like slanging matches, etc. It also allows the moderator to discuss off-line with the user the reasons for the moderator's action. Such a system is not yet in place on the website forum, but is being developed for use as soon as possible. While it may not prevent problems arising in the future, it will at least build in a safety valve." And this from from the first post on this thread.

Admin wrote:
I also intend to add functionality which will make it possible for posts from certain users to go into a moderation queue before being published. This would provide an alternative option to suspension for moderators.

Yet a member has recently been suspended. A relevant question to ask is, will the recently suspended member be placed in a mod' queue after he has served his suspension, as happened to OGW?

To assume that the introduction of a moderation queue "will at least build in a safety valve" is missing the point entirely.  A safety valve needs to be introduced before a moderation queue is even under consideration.  Clearly, the introduction of a moderation queue is to admit the damage has already been done and to assume it will act like a safety valve is like closing the door after the horse has bolted! In fact like events happening here are proving the introduction of a moderation queue is not providing a positive solution but actually becoming a distraction from the main issue of placing moderation under scrutiny from the word go!  So we can democratically establish what works and what don't work in line with our democratic decision making process and DPD can we stay focused on suggesting improvements and not on moderation procedures which have already proven to be faulty and wanting.I'm all for a "safety valve" being introduced, but right at the start of an infringement being notified to a moderator.  And  lets be clear the safety valve should also be an invite to conflict resolution rather than posing as a continual threat of further regulation and sanctions which is exactly the purpose of a moderation queue.And Yahoo ffs they are nothing but a bunch of profiteering fascists bastards.  Indeed, if we adopted their type of software the disputes would still take place behind closed doors and not be open to public scrutiny.  In fact we already have the means of openly conducting a dispute on the forum by using a locked thread exclusive to the moderator and user.Think on it, all party disputes are open to public scrutiny, but resolved by the party membership with documentation.  Why should the moderation procedure on this forum be any different?