The real world

When was the last time that someone accused you of not living in the real world? The definition is a subjective one. What conditions the attitudes, opinions and views of those who are either content to live under the present system of society, or of those who feel the need to modify capitalism to meet their perception of a fairer, more equal society? Leaving aside for the moment the factors which influence the majority into an acceptance of capitalism, (as Marx said, the prevailing ideas in society are those of the ruling class) let us concentrate on the power of the state and its hold over those it governs.

Your attitude towards the state is determined by your position in the political spectrum. The Libertarian Right would like to extend the principle of laissez-faire to Social Services. Education, the National Health Service and Nationalised Industries. This process is already being put into effect by the present government. The “freedom of choice” offered by those who want a free market affecting every aspect of our life is a choice based on the ability to pay for the commodities and services on offer. There is no place in this philosophy for the poor, the weak or the sick. To describe this system of society as envisaged by the Right as the law of the jungle is to libel animals who are incapable of behaving in this manner.

The Leftist view of the state, a view seen through rose-coloured spectacles, is that of the Nanny State. Here the state is perceived as providing care for its citizens from the cradle to the grave. This ideal may have a superficial attractiveness but the underlying supposition is that the capitalist system will continue in its present form. The Left sees the state as providing palliatives to the inherent problems of capitalism. A case of treating the effects and not the cause.

What of the majority of apolitical citizens? Brainwashed from birth into accepting what the ruling class tells them, their view of the functions of the state is an extremely simplistic one. A soap powder commercial once asked. “What is a Mum?” The advertising agency responsible for it then answered its own question with a series of answers designed to elicit the correct emotional response from its audience. Likewise, in order that those who are subject to the power of the state should not look too closely at the prime purpose of the state it utilises whatever means are necessary to ensure that the opinions of the majority mirror those of Auden’s Unknown Citizen. “Our researchers into Public Opinion are content that he held the proper opinions for the time of the year; When there was peace, he was for peace; When there was war he went . . . Was he free? Was he happy? The question is absurd: Had anything been wrong, we should certainly have heard”.

When the political bosses pull the strings a suitable response occurs — Britain is best; Isn’t our monarchy wonderful. It ‘s all the fault of foreigners; Things were different when we still had an Empire . . .

What is the knowledge about itself that the state tries so hard to keep hidden from those that it governs? The state is the public power of coercion created and maintained in human societies by their division into classes. a power which, being clothed with force, makes laws and levies taxes. The state is not just an administrative machine; its centred feature is force. In class societies the state is used by the ruling class to serve its ends. Today the capitalists are the ruling class so the state serves their ends.

The ordinary citizen, aware that secret intelligence organisations like MI5 and MI6 exist, naively believes that the second oldest profession in the world is there to protect their interests. We may safely assume that the majority of these citizens are unaware of the scope of the activities of these security organisations on behalf of their political masters. M15, set up in 1909 has increasingly been used since the 1970s against domestic targets considered subversive. It works closely with the Special Branch which is estimated to have two million personal files, twice as many as MI5. In 1984 the Home Office published guidelines which describe the function of both the Special Branch and MI5 as gathering information about “threats to public order” and defending the realm against “attempts at espionage and sabotage or from the actions of persons and organisations whether directed from within or without the country which may be judged to be subversive to the state”.

Just because you’re paranoid it doesn’t mean that they’re not out to get you. Those of you who are. or have been, members of Left and Right wing radical groups including feminists, pacifists. CND. nationalists and of course socialists will have come to the attention of section F7, a sub-division of MI5’s counter subversion division. Should you believe that you do not fall into any of the categories mentioned, being an upright, sober, patriotic citizen, take heed. Should you believe that all these commies, gays. lesbians. lefties, trade unionists and socialists deserve all they get for daring to question the values of this wonderful society of ours, even a letter to your local rag criticising the state may result in attention from your unfriendly local Special Branch.

Those who believe that it is the plight of others to live under oppressive regimes which practice terror and torture in order to control the working class should perhaps draw a salutary lesson from the fate of Hilda Murrell, an anti-nuclear campaigner and Aunt of Rob Green, an officer aboard the submarine that sank the General Belgrano. during the Falklands War who was murdered at her home. The crime remains unsolved. Issue number 16 of Lobster contains an article by a writer with very close links with government Intelligence Agencies. He points out that before her death Hilda Murrell was the subject of attention by at least five Intelligence Agencies. He concludes. “I am confident beyond any reasonable shadow of a doubt that the death of Miss Murrell was caused by private investigators or security consultants acting on behalf of a government department.”

Moral indignation is not enough, reprehensible as these activities are. Although one person’s terrorist may be another’s freedom fighter the object of the struggle in which they are engaged is likely to be the continuance of capitalism, the system of society which encourages violence, legalised or not. But who carries out these actions on behalf of their respective governments and ultimately the capitalist ruling class? The answer is of course members of the working class. Imbued as they are by notions of misplaced patriotism and devotion to a system of society that exploits them, they continue to gather information for the files on their fellow members of the working class, or even commit murder on behalf of the owning class.

The use of intimidation, torture and coercion is practised worldwide because capitalism is a worldwide system. Mongane Wally Serote of South Africa describes his personal experience of the coercive State in Index On Censorship. May 1988: “Physical torture was extremely intense. I never thought a human being could go to that level, but I saw them do it and they are free men even now, they sleep with their wives, they talk to their children, even now. extremely cruel people, very cruel people. It’s a thing I will never forget. I can’t forget.”

Despite the considerable power that the state has at its command, emanating from the economic power of the ruling class resulting from their monopoly of the means of production and distribution, its influence holds good merely because the working-class allow it. “One man is king only because other men stand in the relation of subjects to him. They, on the contrary, imagine that they are subjects because he is king.” (Footnote, Capital, Volume One). How then may this menacing monster, whose tentacles reach into the lives of everyone, be displaced? Those who believe that the state may be violently overthrown and replaced by a People’s State, or believe that the revolution in Russia has led to a half-way house between capitalism and communism are sadly misguided. The destruction and abolition of the state and of the antagonistic class society will only come, through the ballot box. when the majority of the working class, worldwide, understand and accept the case for supplanting the government of people by the administration of things.
DC

Leave a Reply