LBird wrote:alanjjohnstone

November 2026 › Forums › General discussion › Pannekoek’s theory of science › LBird wrote:alanjjohnstone

#95661
Brian
Participant
LBird wrote:
alanjjohnstone wrote:
What new has been learned by anyone?

You asked for some 'explanation' of the issues, ajj.I've given an analogy of an 'NHS computer system' – did this help you, at all? I've not had much feedback, except for a comment by Brian.It's hard to judge whether the thread has been of any use, unless some other posters (not the main contributors) make an assessment.

All I've observed so far is a discussion on the meaningfulness of the terms used and the social interaction which follows.  There has been quite a few definitions thrown in the pot but alas very few agreements on these definitions.Obviously this is a very difficult subject to discuss let alone to debate and having skimmed through this thread several times I can only come to the conclusion that at this stage the pros and cons need to be established and summarised.  Otherwise its in danger of sidetracking into sociological perspectives like symbol interaction.Personally I'm of the opinion that such discussions are necessary in respect that the working class need to develop and create the philosophical/scientific arguments for itself.