Marxist-Humanist like Raya

#87112
Anonymous
Inactive

Marxist-Humanist like Raya Dunayeskaya believes that capitalism collapsed on 1930 and it was saved by state capitalism. It was a wrong analysis made by her and News and Letter,  because capitalism will not collapse by itself, and the  crisis of 1930 started to recuperate after world war two. News and Letters and the Marxist-Humanists do not have the same conception of socialism-communism as we do, they are a reformist organization.I think Paul Mattick has a much better understanding  of our actual crisis than Andrew Kilman and all the members of the Marxist-humanist trend. Most of the members of News and Letter have been influenced by Dunayeskaya, and some type of cult was created about her writings, and around her personalitySome Marxist-humanists has rejected Lenin’s conception of the vanguard party, but they think that the Soviet Union was a socialist country until Stalin established state capitalism, which is also an incorrect analysis, that is another differentiation between the WSM and the MH.  it is very  close to the analysis made by Leon Trotsky.Some of their members came from the Trotskyite movement, and Dunayeskaya which was the head of the MH movement was one of the personal secretary of Trotsky, she broke with him based on the Hitler-Stalin pact that he supported, but she did not break  away from BolshevismEven that they have rejected some aspect of Leninism, they are Leninists and they think that Lenin adopted a different stand after he read the Science of Logic of Hegel.  Their stand is that Lenin and Trotsky were great socialist revolutionary, and we think that Lenin was a nationalist revolutionary, but he was not a socialist revolutionaryI think Lenin was the same Lenin before and after he read Hegel, and  The State and the Revolution is the worst distortion made to Marx in regard to the conception  of the state, and Lenin was the same Lenin before and after he wrote Materialism and  Empirio-criticism. The problem of Russia was not Stalin, the problem of that country was the mode of production established by the Bolsheviks since the very beginning, those are others  differentiations between the WSM and the MH