Editorial

Capitalism and health care

 On both sides of the Atlantic, the last few months have seen various supposedly alternative models for health care inside capitalism being explored. Barack Obama’s review of US health care provision within his first year in office has met a predictably heated response from the paid lobbyists and cheerleaders of the health insurance industry, as well as other sectors of the US capitalist class with something to lose from any change to the status quo.

 The costs of individual medical insurance being prohibitive, the poor of this so-called first  world nation (46 million of them) are left with Third World levels of care and medical support, and daily “life and debt” decisions.

 Whilst there are some differences between the US and UK healthcare system, we shouldn’t over-exaggerate them. Heated though the US v NHS debate may be, it is essentially a phoney war. From a world socialist perspective, these are just alternative capitalist models for rationing healthcare for the working class

 The US system places a cash register and swipe card console at the foot of your hospital bed. In terms of the immediacy and impact on the patient, the NHS and similar systems in Europe certainly seem a little more ‘civilised’. But there is of course still a reckoning somewhere down the line. The ‘socialised’ systems just remove that decision from the immediacy of the ward. Instead the decision is made at one remove: by an NHS Trust or the government that allocates its funds. The decision isn’t made for you as an individual patient, but for your class as a whole, the working class who constitute some 90 percent of the population.

 The reason the US administration is looking again at how their system is – or isn’t – working, has little to do with how ethical or plain nice it wants its society to be. Instead it is driven by a need to make economies and find the most efficient way to maintain the health of the US workforce. After all, despite the egalitarian claims surrounding it, the introduction of the NHS to the UK had a solid capitalist ‘business case’ behind it and was supported by all main parties. (The cost to the US state per head of population is now approximately twice that in the UK).

 The NHS – and the other examples quoted of ‘socialised’ medicine (e.g. Scandinavian countries) – are not socialism, which we would argue means a moneyless and wageless economy as a whole. However at an individual and emotional level (rather than at a political level), it would be churlish of world socialists to dismiss out of hand the strong empathy and support for the NHS that most workers in Britain have. It is after all support for free access, for the idea that healthcare be freely available to all regardless of wealth.

 At one level, world socialists entirely empathise with this sentiment. But not to the extent of getting caught up in expressing political support for one type of capitalist healthcare system over another: only a social system based on production for use rather than profit for the few, can truly realise this powerful and fundamentally egalitarian desire.
Introducing -The Socialist Party


The Socialist Party is like no other political party in Britain. It is made up of people who have joined together because we want to get rid of the profit system and establish real socialism.

  Our aim is to persuade others to become socialist and act for themselves, organising democratically and without leaders, to bring about the kind of society that we are advocating in this journal.

 We are solely concerned with building a movement of socialists for socialism.
We are not a reformist party with a programme of policies to patch up capitalism.

  We use every possible opportunity to make new socialists. We publish pamphlets and books, as well as CDs, DVDs and various other informative material.

  We also give talks and take part in debates; attend rallies, meetings and demos; run educational conferences; host internet discussion forums, make films presenting our ideas, and contest elections when practical. Socialist literature is available in Arabic, Bengali, Dutch, Esperanto, French, German, Italian, Polish, Spanish, Swedish and Turkish as well as English.

  The more of you who join the Socialist Party the more we will be able to get our ideas across, the more experiences we will be able to draw on and greater will be the new ideas for building the movement which you will be able to bring us.

  The Socialist Party is an organisation of equals. There is no leader and there are no followers.

  So, if you are going to join we want you to be sure that you agree fully with what we stand for and that we are satisfied that you understand the case for socialism.

Contents
Features

  • ‘Global Trends 2025: A Transformed World’.
    An analysis of the US report designed to guide strategic thinking and
    inspire political action on behalf of the U.S. ruling class and its allies.


  • The rise and fall of the ILP
    With proposals to set up a united leftwing party to challenge Labour,
    we look at a previous attempt at this.


  • The disease that is capitalism
    What’s better - treating the symptoms or dealing with the cause?


  • Big Brother and the Robots
    A discussion of a Socialist Party meeting in London entitled ‘Here
    Come the Robots’


  • New roots of confl ict
    The confl icts over oil may give way to another source of military dispute
    – lanthanide metals.

  • The SLP of America: a premature obituary?
    By some accounts, the Socialist Labor Party of America has ceased to
    function.
    		•
    Regulars
    Editorial
    Capitalism and health care

    Letters

     Contact Details
    Meetings

     Cooking the Books 1

    Cooking the Books 2

    Cartoons
    The Irate Itinerant

    Free Lunch


    Pathfinders

    Material World

    Pieces Together

    Tiny Tips

    Book Reviews

    Obituary
    Vincent Littlemore
    50 Years Ago

    Greasy Pole


    Voice from the Back







      Click here for Free sub printout









    Subscription Orders

    should be sent to

     The Socialist Party,
    52 Clapham High Street,
     London SW4 7UN.

    Rates
    One year subscription
    (normal rate)
     £15
    One year subscription (low/unwaged)
     £10
    Europe rate
    £20 (Air mail)
    Rest of world
    £25 (Air mail)
    Voluntary supporters subscription £20 or more. Cheques payable to ‘The Socialist Party of Great Britain’.
    Socialist Standard Online edition                               October 2009