Vol.103 No.1239


Journal of  The Socialist Party - Companion Party of  The World Socialist Movement
                                                                                        


Socialist Standard
Front page image.

Page 1

Contents
Page 2

Editorial
Brown’s no different.
Page 3

Pathfinders
Dawkins more wrong than Gould?

Page 4

Letters. Contact Details
Page 5

Religion or Capitalism: which is the root of evil?
Atheists have been coming out of the closet in recent years. But will these freethinkers also embrace the “heresy” of criticizing capitalism?
Page 6

Continued from above page
Page 7

Cooking the Books 1
That was then.
Page 8

I Believe
It appears there has been a recent proliferation of books published on the subject of defending or promoting atheism or giving ..what isall the fuss about ?
Page 9

Materialism versus spiritism
The scientific method versus superstitions.

Page 10

The postal workers strike
A postal worker reflects on the recent series of strikes.
Page 11

Capitalism is not superior to socialism
The Socialist Party speaker’s contribution to a recent debate at University College Dublin on the motion “That Capitalism is Superior to Socialism in the Modern World”.
Page 12

Another leader falls
The demise of Ming Campbell.
Page 13

Cooking the Books 2
Co-opting the Co-op.
Page 14

Reviews
Who Was Jesus?; Against All
Gods; God Is Not Great..

Page 15

Reviews
..
and more
Page 16

Meetings
Page 17

Obituary
Sean Doherty.

50 Years Ago
Has Bevan Sold the Pass?

Principles
Page 18

Greasy Pole
It’s A Date, Then? Or Not?
Page 19

Voice from the Back
Free Lunch
Page 20
Editorial

Brown’s no different

One of Gordon Brown's first actions as Labour Prime Minister was to appoint as trade minister Digby Jones (former head of the CBI and trade unionists' bête noir). He followed that up with appointments for Alan Sugar (of TV's The Apprentice) and private equity chief Damon Buffini – who presumably doesn't need the cash – to something called a Business Leaders Council.

On policy he has promised a raft of meaningless populist measures, including new powers to stop shops selling alcohol to kids (yeah, that'll work), and more power to hospital matrons to get wards cleaned. Ten thousand laptops have been promised to help police cut down on increasing paperwork (presumably related to all the shops being prosecuted for selling alcohol to kids).

He also cornered the UKIP/BNP vote, making a speech about creating “British jobs for British workers" (which might explain the Digby Jones appointment ?), and still found time in his busy schedule to spend two hours in Downing Street with a previous resident, one Mrs Thatcher. He has of course been even more charitable to the current Tory leader, David Cameron, recently giving home to most of his policies.

So is there anyone left who really thinks that the Labour Party is different from the Tory Party ?

The Labour Party was not invented by the capitalist class. But it might as well have been. It offered a superficially attractive gentle path to social change, but has in reality acted for 100 years as a sop to the discontent of its core support in the majority (working) class.

When in opposition it used the language of democracy and freedom, fairness and equality. But its actions when in government throughout the 20th century speak far far louder. Anti-war campaigners gave it their support then watched aggrieved as Labour purchased expensive missile systems, or frog-marched millions into countless wars around the globe. Trade unionists financed it, then stood by as Labour introduced or extended anti-trade union legislation.

More recently, Labour hasn't really needed to say much at all. No grandiose claims as to how they would nationalise the “commanding heights” of the economy or solve the housing crisis. No taxing the rich “until the pips squeak” For the last 25 years it has been considered enough to simply not be Thatcher, Major, Howard, Cameron... They didn’t put it on their manifestos and election posters but the inspiring message to voters has been "Well we might be bad, but the other lot are worse".

The convenient explanation is to blame it all on “that bloody man” (Tony Blair) for supposedly hijacking the party. The reality however is that the Labour Party, its means and ends, have long since become discredited. Only the rhetoric has changed in the last 20 years. The Labour Party simply never were socialist: the difference now is that they don't have to pretend.

Blair came to power on the basis of not being a Tory; he was allowed to cling onto power for ten years by a Party desperate for an orderly succession to let the next great hope take charge.
And so we come to Gordon Brown, minister's son, radical student and Red Clydeside historian. Will he be any different? Of course he won’t. Do you want to bet?
  Top     Contents page

Introducing
The Socialist Party

The Socialist Party is like no other political party in Britain. It is made up of people who have joined together because we want to get rid of the profit system and establish real socialism.

 Our aim is to persuade others to become socialist and act for themselves, organising democratically and without leaders, to bring about the kind of society that we are advocating in this journal.

 We are solely concerned with building a movement of socialists for socialism. We are not a reformist party with a programme of policies to patch up capitalism.

 We use every possible opportunity to make new socialists. We publish pamphlets and books, as well as CDs, DVDs and various other informative material.

 We also give talks and take part in debates; attend rallies, meetings and demos; run educational conferences; host internet discussion forums, make films presenting our ideas, and contest elections when practical.

 Socialist literature is available in Arabic, Bengali, Dutch, Esperanto, French, German, Italian, Polish, Spanish, Swedish and Turkish as well as English.

 The more of you who join the Socialist Party the more we will be able to get our ideas across, the more experiences we will be able to draw on and greater will be the new ideas for building the movement which you will be able to bring us.

 The Socialist Party is an organisation of equals. There is no leader and there are no followers.

 So, if you are going to join we want you to be sure that you agree fully with what we stand for and that we are satisfied that you understand the case for socialism.



  Top     Contents page
  The Socialist Party