Cooking the Books 1

The theology of interest

Sharia-compliant Islamic banking is apparently expanding with even non-Muslims switching to Islamic banks, reports the Times (12 March). According to the article’s author, Alex Wade, “under Sharia law, the charging or paying of interest is prohibited”. But, since banks do business by borrowing money at one rate of interest and re-lending it a higher rate, how can a bank which does not pay or charge interest exist?

This is to underestimate the subtlety of Islamic theologians, following in the footsteps of their end-of-Middle Ages Catholic and Protestant counterparts. In the Middle Ages the dogma of the Catholic Church banned usury, defined as charging money for a loan. Well, but not quite:

“No man, again, may charge money for a loan. He may, of course, take the profits of partnership, provided that he takes the partner’s risks. He may buy a rent-charge; for the fruits of the earth are produced by nature, not wrung from men. He may demand compensation - interesse - if he is not repaid the principal at the time stipulated. He may ask payments corresponding to any loss he incurs or forgoes. He may purchase an annuity, for the payment is contingent and speculative, not certain” (RH Tawney, Religion and the Rise of Capitalism, ch 1(ii)).

What was banned, then, was only the certainty of being paid a pre-fixed sum of money for the loan. As Tawney pointed out, the very word “interest” derives from one of the ways of getting round the ban on usury.

Islam, too, allows partnerships as well as a number of other arrangements which allow the payment of a pre-fixed sum of money for advancing money. Wade’s article mentions: salaam (“sale contract with deferred delivery”), arboum (“sale contract with a non-refundable deposit”) and murabaha (“deferred sale financing”).

So, while Islamic banks do not borrow money on the money market, they can still make what are in effect loans which bring in money for them. In any event, Islam is not opposed to profits and profit-making since these are regarded as non-certain rewards for advancing money.

In the end the Catholic church was obliged to face reality and, to try to keep the poor from being exploited by usurers, from the middle of the 15th century itself set up bodies to lend money to the poor. These were called monts-de-piété (literally “mounts of piety”), which is still the French word for pawnbroker, though on the Continent these are state-run bodies. They did not spread to England as Protestantism, which triumphed here in the 16th century, had no qualms about lending at interest. As a result pawnbroking has always been a private business here.

And these days in fact a profitable business which, along with cheapo shops like Aldi and Lidl, is doing well in the current depression. The leading pawnbroker firm in Britain is H&T, whose shares are quoted on the Stock Exchange. It has 105 stores and made £10 million profits in 2008 compared with £7.1 million in 2007. It charges 8 percent interest per month.

Wade doesn’t say if there are any Islamic pawnbrokers, but it shouldn’t be difficult to find some imam or mullah to justify this as a form of “deferred sale financing”.
Contents

Features

  • The cult of Irish Republicanism
    The Real IRA and the Continuity IRA represent nothing but the pale
    ghosts of yesterday.


  • Greatness – perceived and real
    The “Great” are only great because ruling-class historians tells us they
    are.


  • It’s election time again
    The manifesto on which Socialist Party candidates will be standing in
    the elections to the European Parliament on 4 June.


  • Whose news?
    Why are high house prices and high profits considered good news?


  • How I got to be a socialist
    “I could hardly fail to notice that all was not well with the world of the
    mid-seventies”.


  • Crassness
    An educational dialogue explaining the workings of modern capitalism
    and rebellion, based on genuine events.


    		•
    Regulars
    Editorial
    Toxic products

    Letters

     Contact Details
    Meetings

     Cooking the Books 1
    The theology of interest

    Cooking the Books 2
    Capitalism, but not as they know it

    Cartoons
    The Irate Itinerant
    Free Lunch

    Pathfinders
    Socialism on drugs

    Material World
    Global Warming

    Pieces Together

    Book Reviews
    Spies, Lies and the War on
    Terror; Why History Matters; Too
    Little, Too Late.

    50 Years Ago
    Turmoil in Tibet

    Greasy Pole
    Bloggers at loggerheads

    Voice from the Back




      Click here for Free sub printout




    Subscription Orders

    should be sent to

     The Socialist Party,
    52 Clapham High Street,
     London SW4 7UN.

    Rates
    One year subscription
    (normal rate)
     £15
    One year subscription (low/unwaged)
     £10
    Europe rate
    £20 (Air mail)
    Rest of world
    £25 (Air mail)
    Voluntary supporters subscription £20 or more. Cheques payable to ‘The Socialist Party of Great Britain’.
    Socialist Standard Online edition                                         May 2009