Page7
Socialist Standard
May 2005
The Death of John Paul II

Josemaria Escriva. Deified by
the Pope, he was ‘The saviour of the
Spanish church’, according to Hitler.
Papal collaboration with fascism.(image) >>>
“the Pope became
just another
reactionary agent of
oppression, like all of
his predecessors”



Few news reports on the Pope's death did not refer to his time in the Vatican during the dying days of the Kremlin's empire.
Some reporters were even bold enough to claim that it was his intervention in the Polish political scene in the 1980s
that eventually led to the fall of the Berlin Wall.

The rise of Solidarity and working class militancy in Poland at the beginning of the 1980s panicked governments around
the world. The 'communists' of eastern Europe feared a growing threat to their rule, while the governments of the West
saw the mobilisation of an angry section of society that could only inspire militancy in their own countries.

While John Paul wished to see the end of Stalinist rule, he was keen this should not be via violent revolution and,
moreover, at the hands of left wing sections of Polish society, but by the right.

Here he had the backing of the USA. In 1980 John Paul granted an audience to a group headed by Solidarity leader Lech
Walesa and in the coming years the Vatican would find tens of millions of dollars to finance Solidarity's struggle.
Make no mistake; the Vatican was not openly supporting the demands of the workers in their struggle against an
undemocratic, unaccountable Stalinist bureaucracy. After all, what was the Vatican if not undemocratic, unaccountable
and bureaucratic? Instead, its aim was to contain the movement, to see it had the guidance of nationalistic and right-leaning
Catholic ideologues and to ensure its confrontation with the Polish leadership did not get out of hand and win larger
international support from workers.

Many news commentators referred to the 473 beatifications under the JP papacy, a figure that is twice the number of saints
made in the previous 400 years. One can only assume that with more social problems facing humanity than at any time
in its history the Pope thought we needed an increase in the number of saints to pray to for help in solving them.
However, among those beatified and elevated to the ranks of the saints by John Paul II was the anti-Semite Pope Pius IX
and Pope Pius XII, the latter being the same Pius who collaborated with the fascist regimes in Spain, Italy and Germany.
Pius XII ordered the Catholic Church in Nazi Germany to steer clear of political activity, to close its political
parties and to stifle its newspapers. Hitler would refer to this Papal move as "a great achievement" and of enormous advantage
in the "fight against international Jewry".

Under Pius' watchful eye, the Catholic Church went on to collaborate in the "racial certification" of all Germans and
refused to openly condemn Hitler when it was known that millions were being sent to the extermination camps.

Also elevated to sainthood was Josemaria Escrivç, the founder of the hierarchical and clandestine Opus Dei in
Madrid in 1928, and described by Hitler as "the saviour of the Spanish church", along with Mother Theresa who, when
questioned on how her opposition to contraception in Calcutta was leading to unnecessary infantile deaths, countered that
even a child who breathed only a few hours meant another soul for heaven. For Mother Theresa, suffering was a blessing
from the almighty, for it enabled carers to reveal their love for the afflicted.

One scandal the press tended to steer clear of - and one humiliation John Paul was keen to ride out on behalf of
Catholicism - was the sexual abuse scandals concerning priests and Church officials. Since the 1950s, 4,450 catholic
clergy in the US alone have been accused of molesting children. The allegations have persisted down the years in spite of a
Vatican decree in the 1960s which threatened anyone exposing child sex abuse within the Church with
excommunication. John Paul continued the cover-up, issuing an edict demanding Church secrecy in child abuse allegations.

The Pope's ruling on the matter was felt to be so conclusive that one leader of a Spanish seminary persuaded his scholars
that he had the Pope's blessing to masturbate them.

John Paul's complicity in attempting to conceal sexual exploitation in theAmerican, Irish, Austrian and other
Churches, and his undermining of the importance of the allegations once they had come to world attention, merely
emphasized the Vatican's double standards on issues of sexual morality.

While covering up the excesses of a sexually frustrated clergy who found it impossible to adhere to the vow of chastity,
John Paul was ever ready to pronounce papal verdicts on homosexuality, sex outside of marriage, divorce, abortion and
the use of birth control.

In recent years, in spite of a growing Aids epidemic which now infects tens of millions in impoverished countries, the
Vatican withdrew its support from those organisations that distributed free condoms.
The head of the Vatican's office on the family, Alfonso Lopez Trujillo, propagated
the lie that the Aids virus can pass through microscopic holes in condoms, and John
Paul referred to the use of condoms as a 'culture of death'. In El Salvador, after a
long struggle by the Church, packets of condoms were printed with the warning
that they did not protect users from the spread of HIV and, in Nigeria, the
archbishop of Nairobi proclaimed that condoms actually caused Aids.

Undoubtedly, millions who looked to the Catholic Church for guidance, who declined the use of protection during sex,
were handed a death sentence. Perhaps millions of women were forced, by fear of the flames of hell, to bring young families
into a world of abject poverty and early death through disease and hunger.

Whilst many saw JP as a champion of democracy and human rights, a one-man Amnesty International as one commentator
suggested in the press, the truth is he was a conscientious defender of the established order of western-style class privilege, even
if he did once refer to elected governments as the spreaders of "nihilism". He might have lambasted as an atheistic dogma what
many refer to as "socialism" (state capitalism) in the Encyclical Centesimus Annus, whether it existed in Eastern
Europe or Central America, but this seems to be his only reason - "socialism" was associated with atheism and therefore was
a serious challenge to rule from Rome

More importantly, the Pope headed an organisation with 1.3 billion followers who were encouraged to put their trust in a god
and to pray to this god to solve the major problems of the day, thus diminishing people's faith in their own ability to sort
out their own problems and undermining the likelihood of workers uniting and organising with a common objective.

Accordingly, the Pope became just another reactionary agent of oppression, like all of his predecessors. And the Vatican's
reactionary credentials are nothing recent.

Indeed, it has been part of the foundation of reaction since the start, whether it was urging the masses to obey the Caesars,
supporting the feudal hierarchical order, opposing the Protestant reformation or siding with the capitalist class against the
workers, determined always to stifle the anger of the oppressed with promises of reward in heaven for their sufferings if
they struggle on uncomplainingly, and an eternity in the sulphurous pits of hell if  they organised to better their lot.
JOHN BISSETT